ExpERIEnce Us

 Our team is dedicated to serving the community and providing exceptional service to our customers.

Charles R. Fisher


Our Agency was started in 1967 by Charles R Fisher at his home in Scotland PA. Even though he sold the business to his son Jeff in 1988, he remained an active part of the day to day activities till his passing on July 6th 2014. Charles (Ross) passed his love for VW Bugs onto his son Jeff, thus the pink bugs.

Jeff Fisher


Prior to buying the agency in 1988, Jeff had worked in the agency full and part time for over 10 years. He had a Certified Insurance Counselors Degree. Jeff enjoys Dey West and Florida in general. He shared a love for VW Bugs with his dad for many years. Charles’ first company car was a 1973 Bug. 

(717) 264-5806


Amanda Vaughn


Amanda has now been here longer han any other licensed agent. Amanda is also very active in our Breast Cancer Projects. Amanda enjoys cooking, baking, shoes and spending time with her two girls. 

(717) 264-5806


Heather Chilcote


(717) 264-5806


Robin Taylor


(717) 264-5806


The Pink Insurance People!

Jeff Fisher Insurance is affiliated with Erie Insurance, Progressive Insurance and Millville Mutual Insurance Company. 

Erie Insurance

Progressive Insurance

Millville Mutual Insurance